Home arrow Resources arrow AJC Articles arrow "PMI Risk Index" Study - 2005-07-30

Your Cart

Show Cart
Your Cart is currently empty.

Login

"PMI Risk Index" Study - 2005-07-30
The major media have been consumed this summer with the possibility that high-flying real estate prices are simply part of an overall real estate bubble, and that when the bubble bursts, our economy will come crashing down around us, probably in flames. These predictions of a price collapse have scared everyone who owns any real estate, and especially those who have invested beyond their own front door.

There’s no question that housing markets have been on fire lately. New home starts have been running at the "unsustainable" rate of nearly two million per year. Sales of resale homes have also been brisk.

But how long can this record pace of sales and price jumps continue?

Well, that question is the subject of a study recently completed by the economists at PMI Mortgage Insurance Company, one of the largest private mortgage insurers in the United States. The results may surprise you, and perhaps impart a little more faith in the stability of your Atlanta real estate investment.

This particular study, called the PMI Risk Index, examines the local real estate market in the 50 largest metro areas of the nation. Their statistical model attempts to predict the likelihood that a specific area will experience a price decline over the next two years.

The data they used to make this determination is interesting:

* First, the researchers consult the latest home price data from the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight at
www.ofheo.gov. As we have said before in this column, the Repeat Sales Index provided by this federal agency is the broadest measure of resales all across the nation. Evidence of change in appreciation leads to calculation of a price "acceleration" rate, which factors into their equation. A negative rate is considered a warning sign that prices may be near a peak.

* Next, the economists at PMI consulted the latest employment numbers for each of the metro areas, as reported by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The idea is to spot signs of future price instability based on weak job growth or loss, and to find cities with strong job numbers as candidates for lowered price risk. The model’s estimated Risk Index increases as employment growth falls.

* Finally, the Risk Index authors calculate an Affordability Index. Their prior research has shown a strong relationship between steep price declines and areas where homes are simply unaffordable for the average worker. This procedure produces a number which is a measure of home affordability based on median household income, past home price appreciation, and the current 30 year fixed home loan interest rate. It defines the conditions that existed in 1995 as equaling 100.

This study brings together a remarkable amount of data, and the results are encouraging for us in the Atlanta area. Here are some highlights:

* Weakening affordability, fueled by low income growth and rapid price appreciation, has put New England, eastern New York, and California metro areas near the top of the risk list.

* Boston was found to be the riskiest housing market in the country, due to high prices and steep unemployment. The study points out that the Boston metro area has lost thousands of jobs in recent years, yet prices have continued to increase sharply. Combine that with a relatively low affordability rating of 83, and the Risk Index assigned a 53% probability that Boston real estate prices will experience a net decrease over the next two years.

* Also in the top ten riskiest metros were San Diego, San Jose, and Los Angeles, all with a Risk Index in excess of 40%. I am not sure I would want to invest in any city that had a 4 in 10 chance of seeing home prices decline over the next 24 months.

One surprise on the list was the overheated Las Vegas residential market, where home prices climbed a remarkable 54% during last year. The study acknowledges the steep price gains, but also factors in a strong local economy and powerful job growth and affordability numbers. Las Vegas ranked only 26 on the list of the 50 riskiest metro areas.

The good news for the Atlanta metro area is a combination of factors.

Ranked 32 on the overall list, Atlanta has seen home prices climb only moderately in recent years, with a 2004 price increase rate below 5%. This is in contrast to a national average of more than 10% for the same period.

In addition, Atlanta’s metro job situation has improved recently, with new jobs being added, but slowly. Our unemployment rate is not a negative factor in the equation.

But perhaps the strongest factor in our rating is the affordability of homes in the Atlanta area. Combining low interest rates with prices well below the national average, Atlanta ranks a high 115 on the affordability index, meaning that a higher percentage of our prospective buyers can actually afford to buy a home here than in many other cities.

Metro Atlanta’s assigned PMI Risk Index is 99. That translates into a likelihood of actual price declines over the next two years of only 9.9%, and that’s a number I think we can all live with.

 
< Prev   Next >

Upcoming Events

John Adams Presents


LANDLORD SURVIVAL TRAINING

with John Adams
Tuesday, February 28th

Being a landlord can be a rewarding experience. It can also be a difficult one if you don't have the knowledge and understanding of what the process requires.

Few schools offer degrees in property management, so most landlords learn "on-the-job" through acquired knowledge and on-the-job experience, essentially re-inventing the wheel. This is an expensive and depressing way to learn anything.

Whether you're a full-time landlord or just getting ready to purchase your first rental property, whether you are a licensed Georgia real estate professional or an accidental landlord, this seminar will help you improve your property's value, increase your cash flow and decrease your expenses, from attracting (and retaining) good tenants to maintaining your property to understanding your rights and obligations under the law.

For more details and to register click HERE

PROPERTY TAX REDUCTION WORKSHOP
with John Adams
Tuesday, March 27th

One of the significant annual expenses faced by any Georgia property owner is ad valorem property tax. Depending on where you live, it can be as high as three percent of the property's fair market value, and it must be paid year after year after year.

As a result, efforts to minimize this expense are not only worthwhile, they are encouraged by Georgia law. The phrase "ad valorem" means that each property is taxed based only on its value, and no one is required to pay a penny more than the minimum the law demands.

At the Property Tax Reduction Workshop, real estate expert John Adams will review the system he has used for over thirty years to reduce valuations and assessments in Georgia counties and municipalities, saving himself literally hundreds of thousands of dollars over the years.

In this 3 hour information packed seminar, John will teach you how to:

1. Understand the legal process of Property Tax Assessment
2. Meet the newly uniform Tax Deadlines
3. File your own Property Tax Return with a realistic valuation
4. Document your PT-50R with facts to support your case
5. Proactively meet with your Appraiser to reach an agreement
6. Protest your Notice of Assessment in an Intelligent manner
7. Give the Assessor an Opportunity to Save Face
8. Appeal to your Board of Equalization, in person or by mail
9. Make Your Case to the BOE
10. Take Your Case to Superior Court if necessary

If you are not doing all these steps now, you are likely costing yourself hundreds or thousands of dollars a year. If you own just one house, you could easily save over a thousand dollars over the next three years. If you own properties valued collectively over a million dollars, you are literally throwing away your profits year after year.

For more details and to register click HERE